Versions :<1 2 3 4 5 Live

Atari 2600 Chess Game From 1977 Beats ChatGPT

Published JUN 11·Updated JUN 12

story

Above: Atari 2600 VCS console. Image credit: Robee Shepherd/Contributor/Moment via Getty Images

The Spin

Techno-skeptic narrative

This experiment perfectly exposes the fundamental flaws of so-called "artificial intelligence." Large language models, such as ChatGPT, are essentially glorified autocomplete systems that generate plausible-sounding text without any genuine understanding, actual reasoning, or game-playing intelligence in specialized domains. The fact that a 1977 chess program can outperform ChatGPT suggests these systems are merely expensive marketing hype designed to inflate tech company valuations.

Retro Dodo TechSpot by Jennifer Shahade

Techno-optimist narrative

While this chess experiment is amusing, it doesn't diminish ChatGPT's remarkable capabilities in language processing, creative writing, and problem-solving across countless domains. Chess requires specialized algorithms and deep game tree analysis, which isn't what large language models were designed for. The comparison is like criticizing a race car for being bad at flying — different tools serve different purposes in the AI toolkit.

The Register Futurism

Metaculus Prediction

There's a 75% chance that an anthropomorphic robot with artificial intelligence will win in a football (soccer) penalty shootout against a professional human player before January 1, 2035, according to the Metaculus prediction community.