Israel

Basic Law on Torah Study Passes First Vote in Israeli Knesset

Is this a moral catastrophe or is the community already changing from within?

Published 1 day ago

Basic Law on Torah Study Passes First Vote in Israeli Knesset

story

Above: Ultra-Orthodox Jewish men protest the recent arrests of ultra-Orthodox draft dodgers, near Bet Lid military prison in Kfar Yona, Israel on June 24. Image credit: Jack Guez/AFP/Getty Images

The Spin

Government-critical narrative

The Haredi draft exemption is a moral catastrophe that has gone on long enough. Soldiers are dying in Gaza and Lebanon while yeshiva students drink tea in peace, and politicians like Aryeh Deri visit draft evaders in detention centers and turn them into heroes. Extending mandatory service for everyone else while Haredi men sit out the war is a profound injustice that Israeli society simply will not accept anymore.

Ynet

Pro-government narrative

The Haredi community is already changing from within, and that matters. Institutions like Beit Midrash Derech Chaim are proving that Torah study, army service and academic achievement can coexist, with roughly 1,000 students enrolled in that model alone. At least 70% of Haredim oppose the disruptive draft protests, and a growing generation is integrating into Israeli society without abandoning religious values. Israelis should avoid making broad generalizations about their fellow citizens.

Jewish News Syndicate (JNS)

Narrative C

Haredi draft dodging is the most contentious issue in Israel and is the starkest challenge to the militaristic nature of Israeli society. It also may prove to be the final nail in the coffin for Netanyahu's coalition, as even ministers from his own party oppose draft exemptions and voters for the Haredi parties are increasingly frustrated with their leaders' inability to prevent punishment for draft dodging.

+972 Magazine