ICE Officer Pleads Not Guilty to Lying About Shooting

Is the Civil Rights Division's review of the agent's shooting standard policy or a political cover-up that shields a badge from accountability?

Published 5 days ago

ICE Officer Pleads Not Guilty to Lying About Shooting

story

Above: An ICE agent in St. Paul, Minnesota, on Jan. 31. Image credit: Octavio Jones/AFP/Getty Images

The Spin

Republican narrative

Civil rights charges require Civil Rights Division review as standard policy, making this decision "collaborative and deliberative," not a political override. Agents are meanwhile facing a documented 1,300% spike in assaults and 8,000% jump in death threats, fueled by rhetoric from sanctuary-city officials. Castro still faces federal charges, just lighter ones.

Donald Trump on U.S. Department of Homeland Security Newsmax Red State

Democratic narrative

An agent fired through the closed door of an occupied home with kids inside, then the official story blamed the victims with a shovel tale that video proved false. Yet Washington killed the civil rights case over a prosecutor's strongest objections, leaving a lesser charge. When the government shoots someone, the public is owed a full accounting, not a badge that doubles as immunity.

Star Tribune ProPublica ACLU of Minnesota