Canada

Carney Likens 'Dangerous Bluff' Alberta Referendum to Brexit

Is this a dangerous gamble or a legitimate stand against an Ottawa?

Published 7 days ago

Carney Likens 'Dangerous Bluff' Alberta Referendum to Brexit

story

Above: Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney in Ottawa, Ontario, on May 14. Image credit: David Kawai/Bloomberg/Getty Images

The Spin

Narrative A

Alberta's push for separation is a dangerous gamble that mirrors Brexit's cautionary tale — voters thought they were sending a message but ended up with consequences they never intended. About 30% support in the province is nowhere near a mandate to blow up the federation, especially during a trade war with the U.S. This movement is being driven by emotional, nationalistic arguments, not sound policy thinking.

Jen Gerson on X Financial Times

Narrative B

The Carney-Smith pipeline deal excluded B.C. and Indigenous Peoples entirely, turning Alberta into a quasi-sovereign negotiating partner while sidelining everyone else. That's not how a federation works. The Assembly of First Nations unanimously called for the MOU to be scrapped, and the federal government may face legal jeopardy over its failure to consult. Ottawa's approach has deepened divisions and Albertans deserve the opportunity the determine their own governance.

Ezra Levant on X The University of British Columbia