Report: Amazon Training AI on Rare Books, Destroying Them After

Is this a cultural catastrophe hiding behind legal loopholes or a smart legal innovation to humanize AI?

Published 2 days ago

Report: Amazon Training AI on Rare Books, Destroying Them After

story

Above: Books on display at an antique book fair in Madrid, Spain, on May 3. Image credit: Jesus Hellin/Europa Press/Getty Images

The Spin

Establishment-critical narrative

Amazon's industrial-scale book destruction is a cultural catastrophe dressed up as innovation. Physical books — especially rare and out-of-print titles — are being obliterated to feed AI models that can't even sustain themselves on their own output, because AI-generated text degrades the very tools it trains. The entire scheme depends on anonymous middlemen and opacity precisely because the companies behind it know the public would never accept it.

Hello, Writer! on Substack 404 Media

Pro-establishment narrative

Buying and scanning physical books for AI training is fully legal under First Sale Doctrine, and a federal judge has already ruled it's fair use. Companies need physical books to ensure the AI models people use are infused with human creations, not just recycled AI-generated slop. While the backlash to books being destroyed is understandable, it's important to remember that these are consensual, private purchases and the authors are compensated.

Verge Forbes

Metaculus Prediction

There's a 50% chance that an AI-generated book will be on the New York Times Best Seller list by May 13, 2030, according to the Metaculus prediction community.