Guardian

Elon Musks X wins appeal to lift block on Australians seeing Charlie Kirk shooting footage

People Daily

Elon Musks X Wins Appeal To Lift Block On Australians Seeing Charlie Kirks Shooting Footage

Firstpost

Elon Musks X wins appeal against Australia ban on Charlie Kirk shooting footage: 'Uphold free speech'

GlobalAffairs

Aaj English TV

Australia allows X users to view Charlie Kirks shooting footage after appeal

Sky News Australia

Social media ban disguising rollout of censorship laws

eSafety Commissioner

Distressing Content

ABC Australia

I tried to outsmart the social media algorithm. Here's how it outsmarted me

The Australian classification review board overturned a decision that blocked Australians from viewing footage of the shooting of conservative influencer Charlie Kirk on social media after Elon Musk's platform X appealed the ruling sought by the eSafety commissioner.

The Australian classification review board overturned a decision that blocked Australians from viewing footage of the shooting of conservative influencer Charlie Kirk on social media after Elon Musk's platform X appealed the ruling sought by the eSafety commissioner.

After Kirk's death at Utah Valley University on September 10, the eSafety commissioner applied to the board to have video of the shooting classified in Australia, and the video was ruled to be refused classification, which allowed eSafety to serve notices on social media platforms ordering them to geo-block the posts from view for Australia-based users.

After Kirk's death at Utah Valley University on September 10, the eSafety commissioner applied to the board to have video of the shooting classified in Australia, and the video was ruled to be refused classification, which allowed eSafety to serve notices on social media platforms ordering them to geo-block the posts from view for Australia-based users.

X appealed against the ruling on two separate Kirk videos and also appealed a ruling on another video deemed refused classification, the attack on Iryna Zarutska on a train in Charlotte, North Carolina in August, and X was successful in all cases.

X appealed against the ruling on two separate Kirk videos and also appealed a ruling on another video deemed refused classification, the attack on Iryna Zarutska on a train in Charlotte, North Carolina in August, and X was successful in all cases.

X argued the Kirk video contained brief violence with no weapon visible, the footage was grainy and the camera moved away from the victim to the crowd quickly, and the video was not excessively detailed, gratuitous or offensive, describing it as a neutral objective record of a notorious public event of historical and political significance.

X argued the Kirk video contained brief violence with no weapon visible, the footage was grainy and the camera moved away from the victim to the crowd quickly, and the video was not excessively detailed, gratuitous or offensive, describing it as a neutral objective record of a notorious public event of historical and political significance.

The majority of the review board agreed that notwithstanding the heinous nature of the event, the video was not gratuitous, exploitative or offensive to the extent that it should be refused classification, but that a more detailed depiction with different editing or commentary might rise to the level of refused classification, and the board changed the classification of the videos to R18+.

The majority of the review board agreed that notwithstanding the heinous nature of the event, the video was not gratuitous, exploitative or offensive to the extent that it should be refused classification, but that a more detailed depiction with different editing or commentary might rise to the level of refused classification, and the board changed the classification of the videos to R18+.

A spokesperson for the eSafety commissioner welcomed the ruling but said the review board's view that the video should instead be R18+ rated means platforms have obligations to prevent R18+ material being displayed to Australians under 18.

Global Government Affairs

A spokesperson for the eSafety commissioner welcomed the ruling but said the review board's view that the video should instead be R18+ rated means platforms have obligations to prevent R18+ material being displayed to Australians under 18.

Guardian #

People Daily #

Firstpost #

Aaj English TV #

Sky News Australia #

eSafety Commissioner #

ABC Australia #

Freedom of Speech

X wins appeal over Australia Kirk video ban

X wins appeal over Australia Kirk video ban

Australia

Censorship

Lawsuits

Legal system

Freedom of speech & expression

Australia Overturns Ban on Charlie Kirk Shooting Video

american-civil-liberties-union

americancivillibertiesunion

amnesty

amnestyinternational

article19

cambridgedictionary

cato

chinadaily.com.cn

civicus-monitor

congress

ebsco

encyclopediabritannica

equality-and-human-rights-commission

fox-news

freedomhouse

gov.uk

journals

libertas-council

liberties.eu

liberty

lordslibrary.parliament.uk

Metaculus

nationalarchives

newyorker

npr-online

nycourts

open-encyclopedia-of-anthropology

people.com

Reuters

stanford

statista

the-fire

thecriticmagazine

thefire

theheritagefoundation

uk-parliament

united-nations

universityofchicagonews

unnews

youtube

Ukraine

troops

Australia Overturns Ban on Charlie Kirk Shooting Video

XAustralia winsOverturns appealBan overon AustraliaCharlie Kirk videoShooting banVideo

Go Deeper

Sign Up for Our Free Newsletters
Sign Up for Our Free Newsletters

Australia Overturns Ban on Charlie Kirk Shooting Video

XAustralia winsOverturns appealBan overon AustraliaCharlie Kirk videoShooting banVideo

Go Deeper

Sign Up for Our Free NewslettersSign Up for Our Free Newsletters

Sign Up for Our Free Newsletters
Sign Up for Our Free Newsletters