The selection process appears to have been influenced by political considerations rather than purely merit-based criteria, with reports suggesting Metreweli's rival Dame Barbara Woodward faced criticism for being "too soft on China" during her tenure as ambassador to Beijing. This "Beijing Barbara" campaign raises questions about whether the appointment was driven by the current government's desire to take a harder stance against China, particularly given concerns about Lord Mandelson's pro-China views as the new US ambassador.