Versions :<1234567891011Live
Snapshot 11:Wed, Sep 11, 2024 4:58:36 AM GMT last edited by Scott

Pacific Island Nations Submit ICC 'Ecocide' Proposal

Pacific Island Nations Submit ICC 'Ecocide' Proposal

Above: Suega Apelu stands in the lagoon on November 28, 2019 in Funafuti, Tuvalu. Image copyright: Mario Tama/Staff/Getty Images News via Getty Images

The Facts

  • On Monday, Vanuatu, Fiji, and Samoa presented a court proposal to the International Criminal Court (ICC), requesting the classification of environmental destruction, or "ecocide," as a crime on par with war crimes and genocide.

  • According to the proposal, ecocide is defined in the proposal as "unlawful or wanton acts, committed with knowledge that there is a substantial likelihood of severe and either widespread or long-term damage to the environment, being caused by those acts."

  • Vanuatu was reportedly the first nation to request the ICC ecocide designation in 2019. According to the country's special envoy for climate change, Ralp Regenvanu, legal recognition of ecocide is an important step towards justice and deterring further environmental destruction.

The Spin

Ecocide, the destruction of nature, should be a global crime. An ICC designation would enable the Paris Agreement to force nations to reduce emissions. A global climate emergency would require nations to modify laws — existing regulations won't save the planet. For Pacific Island nations like Fiji, Vanuatu, and Samoa ecocide is an ever-present and existential threat — countries on the front lines of environmental crisis especially deserve a legal recourse.

"Ecocide", comesthe fromdestruction aof longnature, traditionshould ofbe climatea changeglobal andcrime. environmentalAn alarmism,ICC datingdesignation towould enable the hyperbolicParis "eco-catastrophe"Agreement rhetoricto offorce thenations lateto 1960sreduce emissions. It'sA oneglobal thingclimate toemergency discusswould somerequire common-sensenations adaptationto approachesmodify tolaws a changingexisting environment,regulations but itwon'st asave slipperythe slopeplanet. toFor indulgePacific inIsland apocalypticnations environmentallike catastrophizingFiji, thatVanuatu, hasand realSamoa legalecocide andis policyan implications.ever-present It'sand farexistential morethreat effective tocountries goon downthe afront pathlines of thoughtfulenvironmental analysiscrisis andespecially pragmaticdeserve solutionsa legal recourse.

There's"Ecocide" comes from a 50%long chancetradition thatof climate change and environmental alarmism, dating to the Climatehyperbolic Clock"eco-catastrophe" willrhetoric hitof zerothe bylate Nov1960s. 2028It's one thing to discuss some common-sense adaptation approaches to a changing environment, accordingbut it's a slippery slope to theindulge Metaculusin predictionapocalyptic communityenvironmental catastrophizing that has real legal and policy implications. It's far more effective to go down a path of thoughtful analysis and pragmatic solutions.

Metaculus Prediction


The Controversies



Articles on this story

Sign Up for Our Free Newsletters
Sign Up for Our Free Newsletters

Sign Up!
Sign Up Now!