Versions :<1234Live

Report: Hamas Says Civilian Deaths 'Necessary Sacrifices'

Image copyright: Laurent Van Der Stockt/Contributor/Getty Images News via Getty Images

The Facts

  • Alleged leaked messages of Hamas leader Yahya Sinwar reportedly show that he believes that a high rate of civilian casualties benefits the group politically.

  • Sinwar reportedly believes that Hamas has "Israelis right where we want them,” the Wall Street Journal reported Monday.


The Spin

Pro-Israel narrative

Hamas' ruthlessness was already evident on Oct. 7. Its continued use of Palestinian civilians as human shields is additional evidence of a vile strategy. Israel, in contrast, rigorously avoids targeting civilians, even in an urban setup. Besides, it also acknowledges and takes responsibility for its mistakes, whereas striking and using civilians is Hamas' modus operandi.

Pro-Palestine narrative

Israel's defenders keep saying it doesn't target civilians, yet the evidence suggests otherwise. Israel is intentionally targeting civilians and areas that have been deemed to be "safe zones," not to mention the blockade that has pushed Gaza toward famine. Besides the fact that the validity of these leaks is always in question, this hypocrisy needs to be called out even when criticizing Hamas' cynical calculations.


Metaculus Prediction



Establishment split

CRITICAL

PRO

More neutral establishment stance articles

Sign up to our daily newsletter