Versions :<123456Live

YouTube Blocks Access to Banned Protest Anthem in Hong Kong

Image copyright: Anthony Kwan/Stringer/Getty Images News via Getty Images

The Facts

  • YouTube has geoblocked access to 32 videos that include the popular protest anthem "Glory to Hong Kong" in the semi-autonomous Chinese city, including instrumental and sign language versions.

  • On Wednesday, however, the South China Morning Post found that the song was still available on YouTube after new "backup" versions were uploaded, as well as on other social media and music streaming platforms.

  • This comes after an appeals court in Hong Kong sided with the government last week, ruling that the song cannot be broadcast, performed, shared or reproduced with the intention to incite sedition.


The Spin


Anti-China narrative

Affecting even people whistling on the streets, the ridiculous ban on the "Glory to Hong Kong" protest anthem due to alleged national security concerns was designed to force censorship on tech giants' platforms such as YouTube. China's "one country, two systems" policy is effectively over.


Pro-China narrative

YouTube has been legally forced to remove controversial content around the world, including in the EU and US, so it's hard to understand how the court-ordered removal of a notorious seditious song would affect Hong Kong's reputation. In fact, given that "Glory to Hong Kong" does pose a threat to broader stability, YouTube should ban it globally.


Metaculus Prediction


Go Deeper


Articles on this story

Sign Up for Our Free Newsletters
Sign Up for Our Free Newsletters

Sign Up!
Sign Up Now!