Civil liberties

France Votes to Repeal 1685 Slavery Code Noir

Is this an act of moral clarity or a symbolic gesture that dodges real reparations?

Published 4 days ago

France Votes to Repeal 1685 Slavery Code Noir

story

Above: Max Mathiasin speaks in the lower house of parliament at The National Assembly in Paris, France, on May 28. Image credit: Ludovic Marin/AFP/Getty Images

The Spin

Pro-establishment narrative

France's unanimous 254-0 vote to repeal the Code Noir is a long-overdue act of moral clarity. A 1685 decree that branded human beings as "moveable goods" had no business staying on the books for 341 years. Acknowledging slavery's legacy matters.

Emmanuel Macron on X France 24

Establishment-critical narrative

Scrapping the Code Noir is the bare minimum, and treating it as a victory lets France off the hook for centuries of documented harm that still shapes life in Martinique, Guadeloupe and Haiti today. Structural inequality, systemic racism and Haiti's debt — forced on a free Black nation in 1825 — demand real reparations, not symbolic votes that change nothing. The history isn't over, its consequences are still here.

Josly Ngoma on X Courthouse News Service

Conservative narrative

France cannot build a future if it remains trapped in endless national self-condemnation over crimes committed centuries ago. While repealing the Code Noir is obviously the right thing to do, nations move forward through shared identity and sovereignty, not perpetual repentance politics and divisive racial grievance.

Outofnone on X

Jordan Bardella on X

Groupe Rassemblement National on X