UK in talks with France about deal to swap people seeking asylum
Guardian7 days ago
UK, France Negotiate 'One-for-One' Channel Migrant Deal
Above: U.K. Home Secretary Yvette Cooper and her French counterpart, Minister of the Interior, Bruno Retailleau discuss migration as they stand near to the Canche Barrier on Feb. 27, 2025 in Le Touqet, France. Image copyright: Leon Neal/Getty Images News via Getty Images
The Spin
Left narrative
The U.K. and France are right to intensify cooperation on migration. Dangerous Channel crossings only empower smuggling gangs and put lives at risk. Strengthening enforcement, boosting intelligence sharing, and expanding legal, humane routes like family reunification is the only balanced approach. It’s not just about being harsh—it’s also about being smart, safe, and fair to genuine asylum seekers.
Right narrative
The U.K. and France’s migration policies are failing on all fronts. Both nations are pouring money into half-baked agreements while record numbers of illegal crossings continue. France offers overly generous benefits that draw more arrivals, while Britain talks tough but delivers little. Neither country shows the resolve or clarity needed to protect borders or craft a coherent asylum system.