Supreme Court declines chance to overturn precedent limiting protests outside abortion clinics
CNNFEB 27
US Supreme Court Keeps Abortion Clinic Buffer Zones Intact
Above: Two women holding anti-abortion pamphlets stand just outside of the buffer zone at Planned Parenthood of Western Pennsylvania. Image copyright: Paul Weaver/Contributor/SOPA Images/LightRocket via Getty Images
The Spin
Republican narrative
Buffer zones infringe on constitutional free speech rights and prevent peaceful sidewalk counselors from offering alternative options to women seeking abortions. SCOTUS' refusal to hear these cases allows local governments to silence pro-life voices precisely when and where their message matters most.
Democratic narrative
Buffer zones are essential safety measures that protect patients and healthcare workers from harassment and intimidation while maintaining access to legal medical services. The restrictions are narrow and reasonable — allowing protesters to still express their views while preventing aggressive confrontations.