Versions :<1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Live

Hong Kong Democratic Party Disbands After 30 Years

Is this democratic dismantling through authoritarian reforms, or improved governance ensuring stability and patriotic leadership?

Published DEC 15

Hong Kong Democratic Party Disbands After 30 Years

story

Above: The city skyline is shrouded in dark clouds on Sept. 24 in Hong Kong. Image credit: Li Peiyun/VCG/Getty Images

The Spin

Pro-China narrative

The improved electoral system ensures patriots committed to Hong Kong's stability govern the city, as demonstrated by the successful Legislative Council election where over 1.3 million voters participated in selecting capable lawmakers from diverse backgrounds. This high-quality democracy, tailored to Hong Kong's realities, has solidified consensus among residents to prioritize development, with newly elected legislators poised to collaborate with the government in driving reforms and integrating the city into national progress.

People's Daily XINHUA

Anti-China narrative

Hong Kong's democracy has been systematically dismantled through draconian electoral reforms that slashed directly elected District Council seats from 452 to just 88, imposed vetting committees to block opposition candidates, and prosecuted 47 democrats simply for holding a primary election. The 2023 District Council election exposed this authoritarian charade with a record-low 27.5% turnout after pan-democratic candidates were entirely shut out, while Beijing absurdly declared this rigged process a "real, functioning democracy."

East Asia Forum

Council on Foreign Relations on Youtube