Hamas Releases All Living Israeli Hostages After 737 Days
The Spin
Pro-Israel narrative
This is a diplomatic triumph and a moral victory for Israel. From the outset, it was clear Netanyahu would not relent until all hostages were freed and Israel's objectives met. Through resolute determination, robust military efforts and the invaluable support of President Trump, Israel has achieved this pivotal milestone. Hopefully, the deal will lead to an end to the war, but that will depend on how well the agreement is implemented.
Pro-Palestine narrative
The Palestinian people deserve their inherent right to self-determination and justice. For decades, they have endured occupation, displacement, and systemic oppression. Their struggle for sovereignty, dignity and equality is a universal call for human rights. This is a welcome but fragile ceasefire; international support must continue to prioritize their freedom, land and right to thrive.
Right narrative
This hostage deal marks a dangerous precedent that will inevitably lead to more terrorism. The 250 senior terrorists being released have decades of Israeli blood on their hands and will quickly return to planning attacks. Hamas never sought coexistence but complete elimination of Israel, as evidenced by their maps showing all Israeli territory as "Occupied Palestine."
Left narrative
Hamas has made significant concessions by releasing hostages without guarantees the war would end or Israeli forces would fully withdraw. Hamas gave in to pressure from Arab allies and desperate Gazans demanding relief. The deal itself however leaves key issues, including postwar governance of Gaza, for future negotiations.
Metaculus Prediction
Public Figures
Go Deeper
© 2025 Improve the News Foundation.
All rights reserved.
Version 6.17.0