Tram Collision in Strasbourg Leaves Dozens Injured

story
Above: Firefighters carry an injured person on a stretcher outside the Strasbourg railway station following a collision of two trams in Strasbourg, eastern France, on Jan. 11, 2025.  Image copyright: Frederick Florin/Contributor/AFP via Getty Images

The Facts

  • Two trams collided in a tunnel near Strasbourg, France's central station on Saturday, resulting in an estimated 50 injured passengers.

  • The accident is believed to have occurred when one tram accidentally switched tracks and collided with a stationary tram at the station, causing what appeared to have been one of the vehicles to derail. Some local media have reported that one of the trams was reversing at the time of impact.

Show more

The Spin

Narrative B

While this accident is undoubtedly frightening and should be investigated, France's tram system is a model of efficiency that other European nations should emulate. With 28 networks and more in development, France excels in integrating trams as fast, reliable, and emissions-free urban transport. Local funding through payroll taxes, simple fares, and unified oversight make systems affordable and effective, reducing traffic and boosting social mobility.

Forbes

Narrative A

Despite France's success with trams, Strasbourg's planned extension highlights why residents might oppose such projects. Over 80% of locals criticized a recent €224M plan, citing disruption along major routes like Avenue des Vosges. Concerns over cost, alternative routes, and the impact on city life showcase that trams, while eco-friendly, can face significant public resistance in practice.

Le Figaro