US Senate Panel Says Credit Suisse Violated Plea Deal in Tax Case

story
Image copyright: Getty Images [via Politico]

The Facts

  • The US Senate Finance Committee on Wednesday claimed that Credit Suisse has violated the terms of a 2014 criminal plea deal, citing failures to disclose transfers related to an ongoing tax conspiracy involving more than $100M held by a single family of US taxpayers.

  • The publication of these findings wraps up a two-year investigation led by Sen. Ron Wyden (D-Ore.), which estimates that over $700M is held in secret accounts at the Swiss bank in breach of its deal with the US Justice Department.

Show more

The Spin

Narrative A

Credit Suisse's new leadership does not tolerate tax evasion and has been actively collaborating with US authorities to tackle any past wrongdoing or current concerns. Undeclared accounts are being shut down and any employee who fails to comply with the bank's standards of conduct will be disciplined.

Bloomberg

Narrative B

Though Credit Suisse states that this report focuses on decade-old "legacy issues," the truth of the matter is that the now-troubled bank has disclosed nearly two dozen "potentially undeclared" accounts a full nine years after the plea agreement was put into place. As the Swiss bank's tax evasion scheme defrauding the US remains active, US authorities must take strong punitive action against Credit Suisse to discourage similar behavior elsewhere in the banking sector.

Washington Post

Metaculus Prediction