South Africa: Lawmakers Vote to Suspend Israel Ties, Close Embassy

Image copyright: Wikimedia Commons

The Facts

  • South Africa's Parliament voted 248 to 91 on Tuesday to call for the closure of the Israeli embassy in Pretoria and the suspension of all diplomatic ties with Tel Aviv until a lasting cease-fire in the war in Gaza is reached, amid mounting tensions in Israeli-South African relations.

  • The motion passed a day after Israel recalled its ambassador to South Africa, Eliav Belotserkovsky, "for consultations" following "the latest South African statements" on Israel. South Africa, which hasn't had an ambassador to Israel since 2018, recalled its diplomats from Israel earlier this month.


The Spin

Pro-Palestine narrative

The clear vote of the South African MPs is an impressive testimony to the functioning moral compass of South Africans. From their own history, they know what apartheid means. Now, it is the Israeli apartheid regime and its crimes against humanity in Gaza that demand South Africa's full solidarity with the Palestinian cause. Pretoria has to act on the motion as its history of oppression is the reality of occupied Palestine.

Pro-Israel narrative

This anti-Israel vote is shameful for a nation that was once one of Israel's most valued African partners. Pretoria has emerged as an ignorant Israel critic despite decades of friendship, claiming that Israel is an "apartheid state" and has committed "genocide" against Palestinians. Behind these outrageous allegations lies a geopolitical calculation to strengthen its alliance with developing nations at the expense of its Western ties. If Pretoria follows the parliamentary decision, it will lose its credibility for good.


Metaculus Prediction


Establishment split

CRITICAL

PRO

More neutral establishment stance articles