Ireland Takes UK to Court Over 'Troubles' Amnesty Law

story
Image copyright: Charles McQuillan/Getty Images News via Getty Images

The Facts

  • Ireland announced legal action against the UK government on Wednesday in response to the controversial 'Troubles' amnesty law that gives legal immunity to combatants in the decades-long Northern Ireland conflict.

  • According to Irish Taoiseach [Prime Minister] Leo Varadkar, the government would pursue a judicial review of the "Troubles (legacy and reconciliation) bill" in the European Court of Human Rights, arguing it breached the convention on human rights.

Show more

The Spin

Narrative A

The British government is robbing families of their ability to obtain justice. Thousands of people were murdered and "disappeared" during The Troubles, and these families deserve the option to have their day in court. Perpetrators shouldn't be shielded from being held accountable for the serious human rights abuses they committed.

Al Jazeera

Narrative B

The Legacy and Reconciliation Bill is the best way to provide justice and move forward. Prosecutions for Troubles' era crimes have been largely ineffective, but through a new truth and reconciliation commission, families can receive more information, accountability, and acknowledgment. This legislation is far from perfect, but the conflict is over, and it's time to move forward.

The Irish Times

Metaculus Prediction