The Facts
Indian authorities on Thursday deployed the army and paramilitary forces, imposed a curfew, suspended mobile internet services, and issued "shoot-at-sight" orders, after violence erupted in the country's north-eastern state of Manipur.
At least 13 people died as violent clashes broke out on Wednesday — during a rally organized by the All Tribal Students Union of Manipur — to protest the inclusion of the state's majority non-tribal Meitei community in the Scheduled Tribe (ST) category.
The Spin
Narrative A
The Kukis are right to protest the inclusion of the Meities in the ST list, as the latter is already classified under Scheduled Castes (SC) and Other Backward Classes (OBC) and have access to the opportunities associated with the special status. Giving more privileges to the Meiteis would be unfair and would rob the poor tribals of their ancestral forest land rights, tradition, culture, and livelihood.
Narrative B
The Meiteis were recognized as a tribe before the merger of the princely state of Manipur with the Union of India in 1949; however, they lost their identity as a tribe afterwards. Kukis' protest is a facade, as they are illegal immigrants from neighboring Myanmar who resent the Manipur government's eviction drives to clear their settlements in reserve forest areas.
Narrative C
This violence — which has reopened an old ethnic faultline between the valley-based Meitei community and the hill-based Kuki community — is a complete failure of the state institutions. The Biren Singh-led BJP government remained mute spectators as rioting mobs, criticizing and instigating a High Court order, set the state alight. These events show the sad state of democracy in northeast India.