CMT Pulls Controversial Jason Aldean Music Video

Image copyright: Wikimedia Commons

The Facts

  • On Tuesday, Country Music Television (CMT) removed the music video for singer Jason Aldean's song "Try That in a Small Town," which covers the topic of alleged lawlessness in the US.

  • According to Billboard, the video includes interspersed footage of "flag burning," along with demonstrators "screaming and attacking police in various scenarios, and robbing a convenience store." It juxtaposes the footage with scenes including a girl playing hopscotch and a raised American flag.


The Spin

Left narrative

If setting the image of a courthouse where a Black man was hanged by a White lynch mob against footage from Black Lives Matter protests isn't racist, what is? Jason Aldean was appealing to the rage of conservative White Americans, and doing so successfully based on the track's popularity. Protesting police brutality does not constitute violence, but his insinuations may very well incite racial hatred and violence against Black people.

Right narrative

The left will blow anything out of proportion if it helps them rid American society of pro-gun or anti-urban sentiments. Jason Aldean didn't choose the Maury County courthouse because it was the site of a lynching, but probably because it's a short drive from Nashville and provided an excellent small-town aesthetic for his video. This is far from the first country song to condemn urban violence, but that clearly doesn't matter to those who want to crush this traditional part of American culture.


Metaculus Prediction


Political split

LEFT

RIGHT

More neutral political stance articles