Canada: Public Probe Into Alleged Chinese Election Meddling Ruled Out

Image copyright: Sydney Phoenix/US Department of Homeland Security [via Wikimedia Commons]

The Facts

  • Special rapporteur David Johnston on Tuesday expressed his opposition to a public inquiry into allegations that China attempted to meddle in Canadian elections, instead calling for public hearings. PM Justin Trudeau said he would adhere to these recommendations.

  • Johnston, the former governor general who was appointed in March to examine the election claims, stressed that the classified intelligence he assessed couldn't be disclosed publicly and, therefore, a public review couldn't be done.


The Spin

Right narrative

As Johnston — a former member of the Trudeau Foundation and a friend of the Trudeau family — was appointed specifically to help the Prime Minister cover up Beijing's attacks, this report isn't surprising, though still disgraceful. Instead of censuring the government for mishandling claims of foreign interference, it passed the buck to media outlets to shape public opinion on the issue.

Left narrative

Unless the goal of some Canadian politicians is to fuel a new Cold War, there's no reason to demonize China. It is certain that Beijing seeks to shape reality in its own interests — as every great power does — but allegations of Chinese interference are mainly about suppressing dissent at home, not installing a pro-Chinese government in Canada. Ottawa is right to carefully choose how to react to Chinese actions.


Metaculus Prediction


Political split

LEFT

RIGHT

More neutral political stance articles