The Facts
Controversial social media influencer Andrew Tate has been formally indicted by Romanian authorities on charges of rape, human trafficking, and forming an organized crime group to sexually exploit women.
His brother, Tristan Tate, as well as two women, are also facing charges in connection with the organized crime investigation. Both brothers are British-US dual citizens, with Andrew Tate residing in Romania since 2017.
The Spin
Narrative A
The case of Andrew Tate best exemplifies the adage that you ought to believe someone when they show you who they are. Andrew and his brother built a social media empire off of selling misogyny to impressionable young men, and it seems that their public statements were not solely bluster. The two are facing serious allegations of sexual violence and coercion. The horrific curtain is finally pulled back on their vile brand.
Narrative B
Regardless of what you think of him, Tate has the right to presumed innocence until proven guilty. Besides, widespread gloating over his indictment only entrenches the view of himself and his followers that he is being unjustly persecuted. Both the media and Tate himself benefit from reporting on his every word, and perhaps it is best to deny him further attention and let the legal proceedings take their course.
Narrative C
The criminal case aside, Andrew Tate's popularity should not be viewed through either the lens of "this man is a terrible misogynist" or "this man is the greatest leader of our time." Tate tapped into a modern world where women are excelling exponentially in educational and professional careers, while young men are being fed more and more often a negative narrative surrounding masculinity. It is society's failure to develop a more positive script for modern masculinity compatible with gender equality that has created the vacuum the likes of Tate have been quick to fill.