2 years since Taliban retook Afghanistan, its secluded supreme leader rules from the shadows
CBSAug 02, 2023
The Facts
After nearly seven months in prison, Afghanistan girl's education activist Matiullah Wesa has been freed by the Taliban.
A spokesperson for the Taliban confirmed Wesa's release. The Taliban had not previously officially confirmed Wesa's detention or given a reason. His education organization Pen Path and the UN Mission in Afghanistan confirmed his detention in March of this year, prompting outrage from foreign diplomats and human rights organizations.
The Spin
Pro-establishment narrative
The Taliban has increasingly restricted the rights of women and girls in Afghanistan, banning them from higher education, public places, and most forms of employment. These restrictions will have devastating long-term impacts on the country's future. The education ban has also worsened the country's international standing, further isolating the nation from the international community at a time when Kabul faces huge economic and humanitarian crises. Wesa is right — there is no way for a country to thrive when half of its population is systematically excluded from participating.
Establishment-critical narrative
While the foreign press has taken the story of the Taliban's ban on girl's education and ran with it, the plan has always been a temporary suspension, not a full-out ban. The Taliban's administration is taking steps to resolve this issue and will continue to make efforts to do so, but in the meantime, girls up to sixth grade are still receiving primary school education, and women continue to teach and attend Islamic seminaries, work in the healthcare sector, and teach in some schools. Education in Afghanistan is not as bad as Western-dominated international organizations make it out to be.
