Versions :<1234567Live
Snapshot 7:Tue, Sep 15, 2026 6:06:28 PM GMT last edited by Anna-Lisa

Thirlwall Inquiry: Some Lucy Letby Baby Deaths Were Preventable

Thirlwall Inquiry: Some Lucy Letby Baby Deaths Were Preventable

Was Lucy Letby's guilt settled by two juries and the Thirlwall report or did the inquiry ignore the one question that mattered?
Thirlwall Inquiry: Some Lucy Letby Baby Deaths Were Preventable
Above: Lady Justice Thirlwall at Liverpool Town Hall on Sept. 9, 2024. Image credit: Peter Byrne/Pool/Getty Images

The Spin


TwoMillions jurieswere heardspent theasking evidence,how weigheda ithospital andfailed convictedto stop Lucy Letby, andyet the Thirlwallone reportquestion showsthat themattered Countess ofdid Chestershe ignoredactually warningsdo thatit? could havewas savedruled lives.out Armchairfrom sleuthsthe andstart. trueNo crimeprimary podcastersevidence, wereno notfootage, injust thatan courtroominquiry andbuilt cannoton relitigate a verdictconviction overnow dinner.facing Insteadserious ofchallenge. provingThat thatblind Britain'sspot mostburies prolificthe childreal murdererkillers: isinadequate innocentcare, letbotched theinfection justicecontrol systemand doavoidable itsmedical joberrors that still persist to this day.

MillionsTwo werejuries spentheard askingthe howevidence, aweighed hospitalit failedand toconvicted stop Lucy Letby, yetand the oneThirlwall questionreport thatshows matteredthe Countess didof sheChester actuallyignored dowarnings itthat could washave ruledsaved outlives. fromArmchair thesleuths start.and Notrue primarycrime evidence,podcasters nowere footage,not justin anthat inquirycourtroom builtand oncannot relitigate a convictionverdict nowover facing serious challengedinner. ThatInstead blindof spottrying buriesto theprove realthat killers:Britain's inadequatemost care,prolific botchedchild infectionmurderer controlis andinnocent, avoidablelet medicalthe errorsjustice thatsystem stilldo persistits to this dayjob.


Metaculus Prediction

There's a 75% chance that Lucy Letby's murder convictions will be overturned within 20 years of her trial, according to the Metaculus prediction community.


Public Figures


Go Deeper

© 2026 Improve the News Foundation. All rights reserved.Version 7.4.1

© 2026 Improve the News Foundation.

All rights reserved.

Version 7.4.1