The prosecution'appeals court’s dramaticdecision escalationto fromreduce requestingthe 10sentences andfor 12-yearBoudaoud, sentencesEpsirkhanov toand nowChnina demandingreflects 20a yearsmore formeasured thoseapproach behindto thejustice, haterecognizing campaignindividual revealsroles aand troublingremorse. shiftAfter inthe howprosecution justicerequested is20-year beingterms pursued.for DoublingChnina downand onSefrioui punishment— 14nearly monthsdouble later,the with10- aand different12-year prosecutor'ssentences officesought nowin handling the case,first raisestrial serious— questionsthe aboutcourt consistencyinstead andupheld proportionality inand theconsistency, legalavoiding process.excessively Thisharsh incoherentpenalties approachfor underminesthose confidenceindirectly involved in theSamuel penal system'Paty’s ability to deliver measured justicekilling.