The National Newspaper

NHS Fife 'harassed' Sandie Peggie  but doctor did not, tribunal rules

lbc.co.uk

NHS board harassed nurse Sandie Peggie who complained about trans doctor in female changing room, tribunal rules

Daily Record

10 things you need to know about trans row tribunal

GB News

Suspended NHS nurse was unlawfully harassed in trans changing room case, tribunal rules

Independent

Nurse Sandie Peggie wins part of claim against NHS Fife

The Times

NHS nurse Sandie Peggie wins part of her trans row tribunal

Guardian

Scottish nurse wins part of her tribunal in trans doctor changing room case

The Telegraph

Trans Women Not A Risk In Changing Rooms Says Nhs Tribunal

STV News

NHS board harassed nurse who complained about trans doctor in female changing room

Daily Mail

Nurse Complained Sharing Changing Room Trans Doctor Nhs Trust Claim.Html

The Standard

Aspects of Peggie tribunal findings hugely problematic for women  solicitor

Sex Matters

Judgment Disregards Womens Privacy And Dignity

Nhs.Uk

Statement Judgment Of Employment Tribunal

The Herald

Dr Beth Upton is the real winner in the Sandie Peggie tribunal ruling

Metaculus

Will an openly LGBTQ person be elected President of the United States by 2041?

Spectator (UK)

NHS Fife’s trans toilet U-turn

An employment tribunal ruled that NHS Fife harassed nurse Sandie Peggie by continuing to allow Dr Beth Upton to use female changing facilities after Peggie complained, by taking an unreasonable length of time to investigate allegations against her, by referencing patient care allegations and by instructing her not to discuss the case publicly.

An employment tribunal ruled that NHS Fife harassed nurse Sandie Peggie by continuing to allow Dr Beth Upton to use female changing facilities after Peggie complained, by taking an unreasonable length of time to investigate allegations against her, by referencing patient care allegations and by instructing her not to discuss the case publicly.

The tribunal dismissed all claims Peggie brought against Dr Beth Upton and found that Upton had not falsely claimed Peggie was guilty of harassment, with the tribunal preferring Upton's evidence regarding the Christmas Eve 2023 changing room confrontation at Victoria Hospital in Kirkcaldy.

The tribunal dismissed all claims Peggie brought against Dr Beth Upton and found that Upton had not falsely claimed Peggie was guilty of harassment, with the tribunal preferring Upton's evidence regarding the Christmas Eve 2023 changing room confrontation at Victoria Hospital in Kirkcaldy.

Judge Sandy Kemp ruled that it was initially lawful for NHS Fife to grant Upton permission to use the female changing room, but that once Peggie complained, alternatives should have been addressed and the permission should have been revoked on an interim basis until different work rotas took effect.

Judge Sandy Kemp ruled that it was initially lawful for NHS Fife to grant Upton permission to use the female changing room, but that once Peggie complained, alternatives should have been addressed and the permission should have been revoked on an interim basis until different work rotas took effect.

The tribunal found that the Supreme Court ruling on biological sex did not result in it being inherently unlawful for a trans female who is biologically male under the Equality Act to be given permission to use a female changing room at work, though having gender reassignment as a protected characteristic did not mean permission was necessarily lawful.

The tribunal found that the Supreme Court ruling on biological sex did not result in it being inherently unlawful for a trans female who is biologically male under the Equality Act to be given permission to use a female changing room at work, though having gender reassignment as a protected characteristic did not mean permission was necessarily lawful.

During the hearing, evidence was presented that Peggie shared messages mocking victims of 2022 Pakistan floods that killed thousands, including comparing the country to a bowl of coco pops, which the tribunal called an untruthful attempt to downplay what she had done when she gave her reasons for sharing the content.

During the hearing, evidence was presented that Peggie shared messages mocking victims of 2022 Pakistan floods that killed thousands, including comparing the country to a bowl of coco pops, which the tribunal called an untruthful attempt to downplay what she had done when she gave her reasons for sharing the content.

NHS Fife stated that the employment tribunal unanimously dismissed all allegations against Dr Upton and all allegations against the board apart from four specific aspects of the harassment complaint, and that the organization will work through the judgment details with its legal team to understand what it means for the organization.

NHS Fife stated that the employment tribunal unanimously dismissed all allegations against Dr Upton and all allegations against the board apart from four specific aspects of the harassment complaint, and that the organization will work through the judgment details with its legal team to understand what it means for the organization.

NHS Fife Found to Have Harassed Nurse in Tribunal Ruling

NHS Fife Found to Have Harassed Nurse in Tribunal Ruling

Go Deeper

Articles on this story

Sign Up for Our Free Newsletters
Sign Up for Our Free Newsletters

NHS Fife Found to Have Harassed Nurse in Tribunal Ruling

NHS Fife Found to Have Harassed Nurse in Tribunal Ruling

Go Deeper

Articles on this story

Sign Up for Our Free NewslettersSign Up for Our Free Newsletters

Sign Up for Our Free Newsletters
Sign Up for Our Free Newsletters