What happened to the fuel-control switches on doomed Air India flight 171?
Al Jazeera3 days
TheRushing preliminary evidence points to humanblame error as the likelypilots causeis ofpremature thisand tragedy.irresponsible Blackwhen boxthe recordingsinvestigation clearlyis showfar onefrom pilotcomplete. questioningSimilar whyincidents fuelhave wasoccurred cutdue off,to andsoftware flightmalfunctions dynamicsthat makeautomatically itmoved nearlyfuel impossibleswitches forwithout thepilot flyingintervention, pilotand tothe havepreliminary manipulatedreport thoseprovides switchesno duringdefinitive theevidence criticalof takeoffdeliberate phaseaction. The captain,focus asshould theremain monitoringon pilot,thorough hadinvestigation bothrather thethan accessspeculation andthat opportunitydamages tothe movereputation theof fueldeceased controlcrew switchesmembers.
RushingThe preliminary evidence points to blamehuman error as the pilotslikely iscause prematureof andthis irresponsibletragedy. whenBlack thebox investigationrecordings isclearly farshow fromone complete.pilot Similarquestioning incidentswhy havefuel occurredwas duecut tooff, softwareand malfunctionsflight thatdynamics automaticallymake movedit fuelnearly switchesimpossible withoutfor pilotthe intervention,flying andpilot theto preliminaryhave reportmanipulated providesthose noswitches definitiveduring evidencethe ofcritical deliberatetakeoff actionphase. The focuscaptain, shouldas remainthe onmonitoring thoroughpilot, investigationhad ratherboth thanthe speculationaccess thatand damagesopportunity theto reputationmove ofthe deceasedfuel crewcontrol membersswitches.
Rushing to blame the pilots is premature and irresponsible when the investigation is far from complete. Similar incidents have occurred due to software malfunctions that automatically moved fuel switches without pilot intervention, and the preliminary report provides no definitive evidence of deliberate action. The focus should remain on thorough investigation rather than speculation that damages the reputation of deceased crew members.