India and Canada return ambassadors as Carney and Modi seek to move on from assassination dispute
GuardianJUN 17
This diplomatic reset represents a pragmatic approach to rebuilding crucial economic and strategic ties between two democratic nations. Canada's new leadership under Carney offers a fresh start after Trudeau's confrontational approach damaged relations unnecessarily. The focus should be on shared democratic values and the $9 billion trade relationship that benefits both countries' citizens and businesses.
This diplomatic breakthrough represents a pragmatic reset that prioritizes economic interests and citizen services over political posturing. The $9 billion trade relationship and strong cultural ties through Canada's Indian diaspora demand functional diplomatic channels. Carney's approach shows mature leadership by focusing on shared democratic values and practical cooperation rather than inflammatory accusations.
ThisCanada diplomaticcannot breakthroughsimply isignore acredible pragmaticallegations resetof thattransnational prioritizesrepression economicand interestsassassination andon citizenits servicessoil overfor politicalthe posturingsake of diplomatic convenience. CarneyThe RCMP's approachevidence showsof matureIndian leadershipgovernment byinvolvement focusingin onviolence sharedagainst democraticCanadian valuescitizens anddemands practicalaccountability, cooperationnot ratherjust thana inflammatoryreturn accusationsto business as usual. Protecting diaspora communities from foreign interference must remain a priority.
Canada cannot simply ignoresweep credibleserious allegations of transnational repression andunder assassinationthe onrug its soil for theeconomic sake of diplomatic convenience. The RCMP's evidence of Indian government involvement in violencetargeting against Canadian citizens demandson accountability,Canadian notsoil justrepresents a returnfundamental toviolation businessof assovereignty usualthat requires accountability, not diplomatic normalization. ProtectingRestoring diasporaambassadors communitieswithout fromaddressing foreignthese interferencesecurity mustconcerns remainsends a prioritydangerous message to authoritarian regimes.
Canada cannotcan't simply sweep serious allegations of transnational repression under the rug for economic convenience. The evidence of IndianIndia's government involvement in targeting Canadian citizens on Canadian soil representsis a fundamental violation of sovereignty that requires accountability, not diplomatic normalization. Restoring ambassadors without addressing these security concerns sends a dangerous message to authoritarian regimes.
CanadaBy can'toffering simplypolitical sweepspace seriousand allegationstolerance ofto transnationalsecessionist repressionrhetoric, underCanada theundermined rugIndia's forsovereignty economicand conveniencesecurity concerns. TheCanada's evidencecontinued ofpandering India'sto involvementKhalistani inextremists targetingand Canadianongoing citizenssurveillance onof CanadianIndian soildiplomatic ispersonnel awill fundamentalmake violationit ofchallenging sovereigntyto thatrebuild requiresits accountability,once-strong notties diplomaticwith normalizationIndia.
ByThis offeringdiplomatic politicalbreakthrough spaceis anda tolerancepragmatic toreset secessionistthat rhetoric,prioritizes Canadaeconomic underminedinterests India'sand sovereigntycitizen andservices securityover concernspolitical posturing. CanadaCarney's continuedapproach panderingshows tomature Khalistanileadership extremistsby focusing on shared democratic values and ongoingpractical surveillancecooperation ofrather Indianthan diplomaticinflammatory personnelaccusations. willMeanwhile, makeModi's itfirm challengingdiplomacy has paid off, with both countries now closer to rebuildrebuilding itstrust once-strongand tiesaddressing withshared Indiaglobal challenges.
Canada holdscan't strategicsimply importancesweep toserious Indiaallegations dueof totransnational strongrepression economicunder ties,the energyrug cooperation,for andeconomic aconvenience. significantThe Indianevidence diaspora.of BothIndia's nationsinvolvement collaborate in education,targeting technology,Canadian andcitizens trade.on ThisCanadian resetsoil marksis a pragmaticfundamental stepviolation towardof rebuildingsovereignty trustthat andrequires addressingaccountability, sharednot globaldiplomatic challengesnormalization.
By offering political space and tolerance to secessionist rhetoric, Canada undermined India's sovereignty and security concerns. Canada's continued pandering to Khalistani extremists and ongoing surveillance of Indian diplomatic personnel will make it challenging to rebuild its once-strong ties with India.