Versions :<12345Live>
Snapshot 4:Wed, Nov 20, 2024 4:05:44 PM GMT last edited by Nick

Los Angeles Declares Itself Immigrant 'Sanctuary City'

Los Angeles Declares Itself Immigrant 'Sanctuary City' For Immigrants

Above: People in the audience hold up signs in support of immigrants as the Los Angeles City Council considers a "sanctuary city" ordinance during a meeting at City Hall in Los Angeles, California, on Nov. 19, 2024. Image copyright: ETIENNE LAURENT/Contributor/AFP via Getty Images

The Facts

  • Los Angeles's City Council on Tuesday passed a "sanctuary city" ordinance prohibiting the use of city resources to enforce federal immigration laws. Los Angeles is the US' second-most populated city and, according to the council, home to 1.3M migrants.Los Angeles' City Council on Tuesday passed a "sanctuary city" ordinance prohibiting the use of city resources to implement federal immigration enforcement. Los Angeles is the US' second-most populated city and, according to the council, home to 1.3M migrants.

  • Unanimously passed, the ordinance codifies immigrant protection in the city's municipal law. Los Angeles was declared a “city of sanctuary" during Pres.-elect Donald Trump’s first term but instead through a resolution and an executive order.Unanimously passed, the ordinance codifies protections for immigrants in the city's municipal law. Los Angeles was declared a "city of sanctuary" during Pres.-elect Donald Trump's first term but initially by way of a resolution and an executive order.


The Spin

Los Angeles’s' decision to formalize its sanctuary city status is a principled and pragmatic response to the ongoing immigration debate. The city has reaffirmed its commitment to treating migrants with dignity and humanity, resisting the punitive approach favored by critics. Sanctuary policies build trust between law enforcement and immigrant communities, ensuring public safety by encouraging crime reporting without fear of deportation. Los Angeles has shown that compassion and practical governance can coexist a powerful rebuke to divisive rhetoric and inhumane political stunts likely under a new Trump administration.

Los Angeles's sanctuary city move is symbolic rather than substantive, prioritizing political optics over public safety and fiscal responsibility. By formally shielding undocumented immigrants, including those with criminal records, the city burdens taxpayers while undermining federal law enforcement efforts. Sanctuary policies strain public resources, from education to healthcare, and erode trust in governance as crime concerns mount among voters. InsteadLos ofAngeles' addressing immigration reform holistically, LA’s ideologically-driven grandstanding will harmbackfire thewhen veryit communitiesruns itafoul claimsof toPres.-elect protectTrump's widely popular immigration policies.


Metaculus Prediction



Sign up to our daily newsletter