NYT Defends Piece Alleging Israeli Forces Purposely Shot Children
NYT Defends Piece Alleging Israeli Forces Purposely Shot Children
The Facts
The New York Times on Tuesday defended a piece it published last week alleging that there were multiple cases of Israeli forces in Gaza shooting children in their head or chest. The article, filed as an opinion piece, was based on the testimony of 65 US-based health professionals who had worked in Gaza over the past year.
The war in the enclave broke out on the same day as and in retaliation for the Hamas-led Oct. 7, 2023, attack on southern Israel, in which gunmen killed about 1.2K people and took some 250 hostages to Gaza.Critics said the accounts were inaccurate or fabricated, but the Times claimed to have "rigorously edited this guest essay before publication" and worked to verify its claims. The outlet added that its editors had seen photos too graphic to publish corroborating the claims.
The Spin
The validityaccusations ofagainst thesethis CTrigorously scansscrutinized mustarticle beare questionedcompletely for several reasonsbaseless. TheEverything lackthat ofwas skullincluded fragments, exit wounds, or change in the shapepiece ofwas theverified bulletsmultiple istimes, evidenceincluding thatby theindependent CT scans were fabricated. Additionallyexperts, evenand ifthere the scans are legitimate,photos theresubstantiating isits noclaims evidence that Israeliare forcessimply firedtoo thegraphic bullet, as Hamas is known to kill civilianspublish.
The accusationsvalidity againstof thisthese rigorouslyCT scrutinizedscans articlemust arebe completelyquestioned baselessfor several reasons. EverythingThe thatlack wasof includedskull fragments, exit wounds, or change in the pieceshape wasof verifiedthe multiplebullets times,is includingevidence bythat independentthe expertsCT scans were fabricated. Additionally, andeven thereif the scans are photoslegitimate, substantiatingthere itsis claimsno evidence that areIsraeli simplyforces toofired graphicthe bullet, as Hamas is known to publishkill civilians.
