Versions :<1234567Live>
Snapshot 3:Thu, Sep 12, 2024 7:27:00 PM GMT last edited by MattKalman

Australia Strips Commanders' Medals Over Alleged War Crimes

Australia Strips Commanders' Medals Over Alleged War Crimes

Above: Richard Marles during the Australia-US Ministerial Consultations at the US Naval Academy on Aug. 6, 2024 in Annapolis, Maryland. Image copyright: Chip Somodevilla/Staff/Getty Images News via Getty Images

The Facts

  • Australian Deputy Prime Minister and Minister for Defense Richard Marles has stripped several serving and former military commanders of the Australian Defence Force (ADF) of their medals over alleged war crimes on their watch in Afghanistan.

  • Marles' announcement in parliament on Thursday comes after the 2020 Brereton Report found "credible evidence" that the ADF commanders unlawfully killed 39 people during the war in Afghanistan between 2001 and 2021.Marles' announcement in parliament on Thursday came after the 2020 Brereton Report found "credible evidence" that the ADF commanders unlawfully killed 39 people during the war in Afghanistan between 2001 and 2021.

  • The report alleged that at least 25 ADF personnel who served in Afghanistan forced their juniors to kill unarmed civilians as part of the military's "warrior culture" that went unchecked.The report alleged that at least 25 ADF personnel who served in Afghanistan forced their juniors to kill unarmed civilians as part of, what the report called, the military's "warrior culture" that went unchecked.


The Spin


TheIt's unfair to penalize high-ranking officers, considering the Brereton Report neitherdidn't foundfind evidence that the commanders were aware of the alleged war crimes norand focuseddidn't focus on troops directly accused of the murders. It'sStrippong unfairthese tomedals penalize high-ranking officers for an alleged unlawful act unseen and unknown to them or committed by junior recruits. This decision is a betrayal of the courage, leadership, and sacrifice of soldiers on the battlefield. PunishmentThere ofshould anyonly kind should be administeredpunishment onlyif afteran the officer in question is found guilty by a court of law.


While the commanders' misconduct is a source of national shame, Marles' decision to strip theirthese medals clearly demonstrates Australia's commitment to accountability for those who bring shame to the country's military. These officers can't retain their honors — awarded for leadership in combat — when they're are morally responsible for what occurred under their command. Removing the medals is a courageous thing for theunlawful governmentbehavior to do, and will send the message that when one person conducts an unlawful behavior, it stains the entire unit.


The fact that thehonored top commanders, includinghave Australian Defence Force Chief Angus Campbell — who received a Distinguished Service Cross for overseeing Australian troops in Afghanistan — had been let off the hook and didnaren't facefacing the prospect of having their medals stripped shows that responsibility and accountability don't reach far enough up the chain of command. The Australian military isnhasn't been let down by its senior officers orand their subordinates but by a lack of moral courage at higher headquarters.


More than 39K Australians served in Afghanistan, and they don't deserve to be painted as war criminals. This decision will significantly strain the veterans, especially soldiers who weren't involved in alleged war crimes. Additionally, the timing of Marles' decision — which comes just days after the Royal Commission's findings into the startling rate of veteran suicide were released — is insensitive, atrocious, and cruel. It's a bloody spat at the feet of the thousands of young recruits who fought terrorism on a foreign country's behalf.


Metaculus Prediction


Articles on this story

Sign Up for Our Free Newsletters
Sign Up for Our Free Newsletters

Sign Up!
Sign Up Now!